Spencer House Bed & Breakfast

Spencer House Bed & Breakfast Navigation Menu

Reservations

BEST RATE GUARANTEED

Reservations

BOOK DIRECT BENEFITS AND FEATURES

  • Lowest Rates Guaranteed
  • See all Available Rooms
  • Enhancements Available
  • Experience Packages Available
  • No additional Fees to OTA’s
  • Complimentary Digital Local Guide
X
Collage of handmade chocolates from Pulakos Chocolates in Erie, PA, including a box of assorted milk chocolates and a card reading “Chocolate is the Answer.”

Move Over, Hershey: A Chocolate Lover’s Guide to Erie, PA

Hershey may call itself the sweetest place on earth, but here in Erie we have a pretty good case of our own. Three family chocolate shops have been making candy in this city for generations, and their stories are tied together in ways that surprise a lot of people, even folks who grew up here.


Pulakos: Erie’s Oldest Chocolate Company

The Pulakos story starts with George P. Pulakos, who came to America from Greece in the late 1890s. He spent about ten years making candy at home and selling it from a pushcart on the streets of Philadelphia before moving to Erie in 1903. That happens to be the same year Milton Hershey broke ground on his famous factory.

Three Pulakos storefronts through the years: an early George Pulakos & Sons shop with family members out front, the Pulakos 926 sign on State Street, and today’s Parade Street store in Erie, PA.George opened his first shop on State Street in 1903. In 1916 he moved into an ornate building at 926 State Street, and he liked the address so much he worked it into the company name: Pulakos 926 Candies. In those early years the shop had a bakery, a café and tea room and an ice cream parlor in addition to the chocolate shop. As the business grew, the family opened additional shops around Erie and in Wesleyville. The 926 building was home base for more than fifty years, until it was taken by eminent domain and torn down. It was so solidly built that it reportedly took four wrecking balls to bring it down. Today that spot is the courtyard for the Bowie Apartments.

George passed away in 1920, and his son Constantine, known to everyone as Gus, took over while still a young man. Gus was a true candy enthusiast and was known forVintage black-and-white photo of an elaborate Christmas window display at Pulakos 926 in Erie, PA, with a candy house, a sleigh, holiday garland, and boxed chocolates. Gus Pulakos was known for creative window displays throughout the year the amazingly detailed chocolate and candy creations he would create for the window display. He wrote a book on the history of confectionery called Rambling Into Romantic Candy Antiquity (1966), and the Gus Pulakos Candy School, a short course for candy makers, was held right at the store. The business stayed in the Pulakos family for four generations.

In 1971, Pulakos moved its chocolate production to East 26th and Parade Street, where its chocolates are still made today. Much of the work is still done by hand, with candies boxed by hand, centers laid out on the original marble tables, and copper pots heated over open flames. Pulakos even makes its own old-fashioned marshmallow. The Parade Street store features a room with a display of historical equipment, chocolate molds, and photos. In 2009 George A. Pulakos sold the business to Joseph Hilbert, who kept the original recipes and traditions going. In 2025 the company opened a third store in Colony Plaza in Millcreek, joining the Parade Street flagship and its shop just outside the Millcreek Mall. The new store features the shop’s original vintage cast iron signs and offers ice cream like the original store.

Today the shop is in the hands of owners Randy and Sara Harris, who purchased it in 2023. Randy, who serves as production manager, and Sara, who serves as operations manager, both grew up on Pulakos Chocolates. As Sara puts it:

“It’s a huge responsibility taking on a local legacy company. We want to be good stewards of the past and continue to grow into the future. We’ve grown up with Pulakos, and we are proud and excited to share our chocolates with those who have never had them. Pulakos is a staple in family traditions and celebrations in Erie, and we are lucky enough to hear the stories customers share each season. Those traditions carry on even after someone moves away. They regularly order sponge candy and their favorites to be shipped.”


Stefanelli’s: an Italian candy maker’s dream

Romolo Stefanelli was born just outside Rome and came to the United States in 1906 at about 14 years old. Family lore says he left Italy to avoid the priesthood. In New York he went straight into the candy trade, working at Loft’s Candies in Manhattan, where he eventually ran the hard candy division. He also spent time at other big names in the business.

Stefanelli’s Candies in Erie, PA: the storefront with its teal script sign, flanked by curved glass cases of chocolates and a long counter of boxed and bagged candies. A trip to Erie to stand up at his brother’s wedding changed everything. That’s where Romolo met his wife, Elizabeth. When hard times and sugar shortages cost them their jobs in New York, the couple came back to Erie and started making candy in the basement of their home at 414 Raspberry Street. They later opened a shop at 2054 West Eighth Street, which is still Stefanelli’s Candies today. It was a true family operation, with Elizabeth, three of her sisters, Romolo’s brother, their sons, and cousins all pitching in.

Here is a fun bit of trivia for your next sponge candy craving. According to the StefanelliTwo pieces of chocolate-covered sponge candy cut open to show the light, airy golden toffee inside. family, Loft’s had experimented with aerating hard candy using baking soda as a summer treat, but it was too sticky to work with and they dropped it. As the family tells the story, Romolo solved the problem by covering the candy in chocolate, helping create the sponge candy tradition that Erie loves today.

Romolo’s sons, Tony Sr. and Art, carried on the business. Art, who created the shop’s well loved meltaways, eventually bought out his brother and in 1993 sold Stefanelli’s to Frank DeDionisio. Frank kept the recipes the same, started staying open year round, and grew the business to four locations around the city. In 2015 Joe and Kathy Stainbrook of Meadville bought Stefanelli’s, and their daughters now run it. Stefanelli’s still uses copper kettles over open flames and pulls hard candy by hand, and in 2023 the family opened a new production facility and shop in Meadville.


Romolo: a grandson carries on the name

This is where the story comes full circle. Tony Stefanelli, Romolo’s grandson, was practically raised in the family candy shop and was stirring kettles of caramel by age eight. He apprenticed under his grandfather, his father, and his uncle Art, worked in the family business for about twenty years, and also built a career as a jazz bassist along the way.

When Stefanelli’s was sold outside the family, Tony decided to keep his grandfather’s legacy going in his own way. In November 1994 he and his wife Jennie opened Romolo Chocolates in Schaal Plaza on West 12th Street, naming it after Grandpa Romolo. In 2003 they moved into their Mediterranean style building at 1525 West Eighth Street, which includes the chocolate shop, a gift shop, and the Cocoa Café, where Jennie serves as pastry chef.

Romolo Chocolates in Erie, PA: the Mediterranean-style building with its arched entrance, flanked by two views of the candy shop’s glass display cases.Tony is one of only a small group of Master Confectioners certified by Retail Confectioners International, and his sons Anthony and Roman are fourth generation candy makers. Among its best-known creations is Grandpa Romolo’s Famous Sponge Candy, a recipe that connects today’s chocolate shop to the family’s earliest candy-making traditions.


A friendly rivalry worth tasting

For much of the last century, Pulakos and the Stefanelli family shops were longtime favorites among Erie chocolate lovers, with a friendly rivalry between them. Today, all three have a shop along West Eighth Street. Romolo and Stefanelli’s sit just down the road from each other, and Pulakos joined them in 2025 with its Colony Plaza store. Pulakos still makes its chocolates at its Parade Street flagship, its home since 1971, carrying on more than 120 years of candy making in Erie. That makes a chocolate tasting tour about as easy as it gets. All three make their own version of Erie’s beloved sponge candy, so why not sample each and decide which one you like best? Just don’t expect the locals to agree on a winner.


If you stay with us at Spencer House, you’ll get a head start. Every guest finds a complimentary Pulakos candy bar waiting in their room at check-in, our small way of sharing a piece of Erie history with you. If you’d like to make your stay even sweeter, you can add chocolate covered strawberries from one of our local chocolatiers to your reservation, or book our Wine and Chocolate package featuring local wine and Pulakos chocolates. Once you’ve had a taste, we’d love to point you toward all three shops so you can find your own favorite before you head home. Just ask Lisa or me at breakfast and we’ll be happy to share where we like to stop.


Frequently Asked Questions

What is the oldest chocolate shop in Erie, PA? Pulakos Chocolates is Erie’s oldest, making candy in the city since 1903. That’s the same year Milton Hershey broke ground on his factory in Hershey, Pennsylvania.

What is sponge candy? Sponge candy is a light, crunchy, airy toffee covered in chocolate. It’s a favorite in Erie and the surrounding region, and all three shops make their own version. According to the Stefanelli family, Romolo Stefanelli came up with the idea of coating it in chocolate.

Are Romolo Chocolates and Stefanelli’s Candies related? Yes. Romolo Stefanelli founded Stefanelli’s Candies, and his grandson Tony opened Romolo Chocolates in 1994, naming it after him. Stefanelli’s has since been sold to other families, but both shops share the same roots.

Where can you see some of Erie’s chocolate history? Stop by the Pulakos store on Parade Street, which has a room displaying historical candy making equipment, chocolate molds, and photos from more than 120 years of making chocolate in Erie.

Photo credit to Pulakos Chocolates for the historic photos.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Call for Assistance
(814) 464-0419
Text us Button Icon
Call Business Icon

Call

Rooms button Icon

Rooms

Direstions Map Icon

Map

Photo Gallery Icon

Gallery

RESERVE Opens Availability Calendar Window